Quote Originally Posted by ironwoman05 View Post
I get them when I come back to the thread, like the next day, which I do through "settings".

So when I want to make a new reply, all the old quotes also come up unless I go back and individually uncheck or individually delete the quotes in the reply window.
When you quick the multi quote button on a reply it takes the content of that reply and sticks it in a cookie. When you reply, the cookie should be cleared. If you don't reply, they'll stay in the cookie for a long time.

If you're finding that you quote, reply, and they still stick around, lets try forcibly resetting your forum cache. CTRL-F5.